Do ESG Funds Always Adhere to ESG Principles?

As You Sow’s researchers sought to determine how 94 funds with ESG in their name defined ESG in their prospectuses. Using natural language processing, the team looked at the terminology used to describe the fund’s strategy (e.g., defensive or ambiguous). Then, they looked for fossil fuels, weapons, tobacco, and other non-ESG holdings.

 

While terminology alone couldn’t accurately predict greenwashing, the researchers determined that 60 of the 94 funds held a significant number of non-ESG stocks in their portfolios. The team also found defensive phrases were common among good and bad funds, making it hard for investors to determine their actual impact.

The advocacy group met with the SEC to share their findings and recommendations. While the SEC has threatened potential ESG investigations, greenwashing remains prevalent across the market. As You Sow recommended that prospectuses be produced in a machine-readable format to analyze ESG wording and more easily identify greenwashing.

There are many ways for investors to avoid greenwashing when selecting funds for their portfolios. Of course, the easiest way is to look at the fund’s portfolio. For example, the FlexShares STOXX U.S. ESG Impact Index Fund (ESG) contains Exxon Mobil, Altria Group, and other companies that don’t typically rate well on ESG scales.

Another way to avoid greenwashing is to seek inclusionary ESG funds. Rather than removing low-rated companies, these funds seek out companies that actively address ESG-related concerns. JPMorgan’s new Climate Change Solutions ETF (TEMP) is an excellent example of a fund that invests in companies addressing climate change.

Finally, many rating companies are incorporating ESG into their offerings. For example, Morningstar has a sustainability tab that looks at each ESG pillar and assigns a score based on the fund’s portfolio. You can also easily see the percentage of a portfolio invested in fossil fuels and a carbon risk score while comparing the fund with its peers.

Be sure to check our Portfolio Management Channel to learn more about different portfolio rebalancing strategies.

As You Sow’s study underscores the prevalence of greenwashing across mutual funds and ETFs. While the advocacy group is pushing for change, the SEC has been slow to take any enforcement action to date. In the meantime, investors interested in ESG funds should carefully analyze each fund’s portfolio for non-ESG holdings while looking at its strategy to determine how it vets ESG qualifications.

Make sure to visit our News section to catch up with the latest news about income investing.